, ,

What Happens When Public Transit Is Free? Philadelphia’s Zero Fare Program Offers Early Clues

Sebastian Jilke, McCourt School professor and co-director of the Better Government Lab, explains what a randomized evaluation of Philadelphia’s pilot Zero Fare program reveals about ridership, access and trust in local government.

Since 2023, the City of Philadelphia’s Zero Fare program has given free rides on the Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority (SEPTA) to select low-income residents. SEPTA is the regional public transit agency that runs the buses, subway, trolleys and regional lines that serve Philadelphia and its surrounding counties. More people qualified for the pilot program than the City could afford to serve, so most participants were chosen by lottery and enrolled automatically. This design choice also created an opportunity for the Better Government Lab (BGL) to examine a randomized controlled trial of what happens when riders no longer have to pay for public transit.

In an October update on the program, the City of Philadelphia highlighted early findings from BGL, co-directed by McCourt Professor Sebastian Jilke. The Lab, which is actively evaluating Zero Fare, found in its policy brief that the program increased ridership across every racial and ethnic group, age group and employment status, with the biggest gains among people who had rarely ridden before. Participants also reported greater trust in their city government.

In this Policy Insights Q&A, Jilke explains how the study came together, what the early findings show and what other local governments and policymakers can learn from Philadelphia’s pilot program.

Expert Insights from Georgetown University Faculty

Sebastian Jilke
Sebastian Jilke


Sebastian Jilke is a professor at the McCourt School of Public Policy. He also co-directs BGL, a joint research center of Georgetown’s McCourt School and the Ford School at the University of Michigan. Jilke is also affiliated with the Office of Evaluation Sciences and was an academic research affiliate with the Department of Homeland Security and the U.S. Office of Personnel Management.

His research focuses on government reform, citizen-state interactions and program evaluation in the context of improving economic mobility through enhanced state capacity. He uses rigorous evaluation methods to understand how institutional arrangements, administrative processes and program design affect citizen experiences and outcomes. 

Q1

How did the Better Government Lab become involved in evaluating Philadelphia’s Zero Fare program, and what central questions does your research aim to answer?

Sebastian: A former collaborator of mine from my time in the federal government connected me with the city team working on Zero Fare. Together with McCourt Assistant Professor Krista Ruffini, we submitted an evaluation proposal and were selected. We now work closely with the city’s Managing Director’s Office on the project.

Our research asks whether the program works, in which ways, and for whom. In doing so, we focus on three sets of outcomes.

The first is whether free transportation changes how often people use public transit in the city and for what kinds of trips. The second examines if better access to transit leads to broader gains in well-being, such as employment, earnings, health and household finances. The third outcome is whether the program changes how people view their city government.

Q2

Philadelphia selected most participants through a lottery. Why does that design make the program especially valuable to study, and how has your team used it in your analysis?

Sebastian: The reason for using a lottery to allocate Zero Fare cards to residents was that there were more eligible residents than the program could fund. A lottery is fair to residents, and also creates the conditions for a randomized controlled trial — often called the gold standard of program evaluation. Because cards were randomly allocated to eligible people, chance alone decided who received a card. This means any difference we see afterward in those who received cards versus those who didn’t can be attributed to the program.

The second advantage of the design is that nobody had to apply for the program, and the city didn’t need to expend additional resources to recruit participants. Instead, the city used existing administrative records to identify eligible residents and enrolled them automatically. This means we can measure the effect of offering free transit to the whole eligible population, not just to people motivated enough to sign up.

Altogether, we compare 21,500 low-income residents who were mailed a Zero Fare card between October 2023 and January 2024 with a similarly sized control group who were not. We used four surveys: one baseline before cards were mailed and three follow-ups after cards were sent, plus two rounds of travel diaries collected between September 2023 and spring 2025. 

Q3

Your initial policy brief found that Zero Fare substantially increased SEPTA ridership across every racial and ethnic group, age group and employment status. What do these results tell us about how cost shapes people’s access to transit, and did any of the findings surprise you?

Sebastian: Transit costs can be a barrier for everyone with low income, regardless of race, ethnicity, age or employment status. Once fares were removed, people in every one of those groups rode more. 

Card recipients were 15 percentage points more likely to ride SEPTA at least once a month, which corresponds to about a 24% increase. Weekly ridership increased by about 46% and daily riding by about 50%. Travel diaries also showed that recipients used transit more for every kind of trip, from work and school to doctor’s visits and seeing family and friends.

What surprised us most was where the gains came from. Most people in the control group used transit already at least occasionally. For instance, about 63% of them rode on SEPTA at least once a month. The largest increase, however, came from people who had been riding the least. Those who rode less than once a week before the program were more than twice as likely to become weekly riders. So Zero Fare turned occasional riders into regular ones, and this uptick in ridership stayed high for the entire duration of the study.

Q4

The brief also found that participants reported greater trust in city government. What might explain that connection, and why is it significant for policymakers?

Sebastian: Across all three follow-up surveys, we found that people who received Zero Fare were about 3 percentage points more likely to say they trust the city to do the right thing most or all of the time. The effect corresponds to a 10% increase, is modest in size, and it did not fade over time. We did not find a statistically significant change in trust in the federal government.

Next to the actual benefit itself, we think that the way the program was delivered mattered. Zero Fare is a visible city benefit, and the actual Zero Fare transit cards are branded as a city product. At the same time, benefit enrollment asked practically nothing of people: no prior paperwork, renewal processes, or proof or eligibility. People were automatically enrolled, received a card and used it regularly. In sum, this was a clear low-burden benefit that came from the city directly. Experiencing a low-burden benefit such as Zero Fare may teach recipients something about the city; it cares about people like them, and makes program participation hassle-free.

Our results suggest that low-burden programs that deliver a tangible benefit that is easy to use can shape how people see their government.

Q5

Your team plans to release further analysis in the coming months. What questions will that work address, and what lessons should other local governments considering similar programs draw from Philadelphia’s experience?

Sebastian: Up until this point, our team has solely relied on surveys, travel diaries and SEPTA tap data. Our next analyses use state and city administrative records to examine outcomes such as employment and earnings, health care use, and participation in other benefit programs. These outcomes are more consequential economically, but they also take longer to change. 

For local governments, we can extract three broad lessons. First, removing transit fares substantially increases transit use among low-income residents, especially among those who report to ride less. Second, automatic enrollment helped the program to reach people, as an accompanying process evaluation by the Urban Institute also found. Third, the easy-to-use, low-burden transit benefit led to higher levels of trust in local government.